A Randomized Controlled Trial of Negative Co-Payments: The CHORD Trial
The American Journal of Managed Care
Objectives: Value-based insurance designs are being widely used. We undertook this study to examine whether a financial incentive that lowered co-payments for blood pressure medications below $0 improved blood pressure control among patients with poorly controlled hypertension.
Study Design: Randomized controlled trial.
Methods: Participants from 3 Pennsylvania hospitals (n = 337) were randomly assigned to: a) be paid $8 per medication per month for filling blood pressure prescriptions, b) a computerized behavioral intervention (CBI), c) both payment and CBI, or d) usual care. The primary outcome was change in blood pressure between baseline and 12 months post enrollment. We also measured adherence using the medication possession ratio in a subset of participants.
Results: There were no significant interactions between the incentive and the CBI interventions. There were no significant changes in medication possession ratio in the treatment group. Blood pressure decreased among all participants, but to a similar degree between the financial incentive and control groups. Systolic blood pressure (SBP) dropped 13.7 mm Hg for the incentive group versus 10.0 mm Hg for the control group (difference = –3.7; 95% CI, –9.0 to 1.6; P = .17). The proportion of patients with blood pressure under control 12 months post enrollment was 35.6% of the incentive group versus 27.7% of the control group (odds ratio, 1.4; 95% CI, 0.8-2.5; P = .19). Diabetics in the incentive group had an average drop in SBP of 12.7 mm Hg between baseline and 12 months compared with 4.0 mm Hg in the control group (P = .02). Patients in the incentive group without diabetes experienced average SBP reductions of 15.0 mm Hg, compared with 16.3 mm Hg for control group nondiabetics (P = .71).
Conclusions: Among patients with poorly controlled blood pressure, financial incentives—as implemented in this trial—did not improve blood pressure control or adherence except among patients with diabetes.
Volpp, Kevin G., Andrea B. Troxel, Judith A. Long, Said A. Ibrahim, Dina Appleby, J. Otis Smith, Jalpa A. Doshi, Jane Jaskowiak, Marie Helweg-Larsen, Stephen E. Kimmel, Jingsan Zhu, Yuanyuan Tao, Wei Yang, John H. Holmes, Dominick L. Frosch, Katrina Armstrong, Shiriki Kumanyika, Kjell Enge, Raymond R. Townsend, and Nirmal Joshi. "A Randomized Controlled Trial of Negative Co-Payments: The CHORD Trial." The American Journal of Managed Care 21, no. 9 (2015): E465-E473. http://www.ajmc.com/journals/issue/2015/2015-vol21-n8/a-randomized-controlled-trial-of-negative--co-payments-the-chord-trial